Client Reviews That Speak for Themselves

“I had an outstanding experience with Lieb at Law. From the first consultation with Mr. Lieb who guaranteed he would get results, to the resolution of my case, the entire team was professional, responsive, and genuinely invested in achieving the best outcome for me. Lauren is a gem who has true intuition and insight. Kimberly is an amazing attorney who always availed herself to me and made me you feel comfortable. The team explained everything clearly, answered all my questions, and kept me updated every step of the way. I truly felt supported and heard throughout the process. Their legal expertise combined with top-tier client service makes them a firm I highly recommend. If you’re looking for trustworthy, skilled attorneys who go above and beyond, this is the team you want on your side.”

— Anonymous

“I am deeply grateful for the exceptional assistance I received from Lieb at Law. As a first-generation college graduate without extensive social connections, finding the right lawyer was a challenging task. From the moment I reached out, Andrew Lieb at Lieb at Law welcomed me, expressing a genuine commitment to help a fellow Smithtown friend. Navigating my case, which involved the recognition and defense of mental and emotional health under disability rights in housing issues - was no easy feat. Many lawyers hesitated to take on my case due to its complexities and it being a grey area still. However, Lieb at Law not only accepted the challenge, but provided clear and confident guidance throughout the entire process. Natalie Donaldson and the entire team at Lieb at Law supported me diligently over the course of more than a year, demonstrating patience. Although my case may be small in their overall operations, the impact on my life was profound. I am sincerely thankful for their unwavering support and commitment to my case. For anyone seeking compassionate and knowledgeable legal assistance, I highly recommend Lieb at Law.”

— Gbrad

“I had the privilege of working with attorney Natalie Donaldson when I was facing an ethics complaint in my role as a realtor. From our very first meeting, Natalie was knowledgeable, strategic, and incredibly reassuring. She took the time to understand every detail of my case, built a strong defense, and communicated clearly and confidently throughout the process. Thanks to her expertise and dedication, we won the case. If you're looking for a sharp, professional, and effective attorney who will fight for you, I highly recommend Natalie Donaldson.”

— Rachel Tabibov

“The team at Lieb at Law is unparalleled in their dedication, talent, and commitment. Andrew, Cheryl, and everyone at the firm are like legal sharks—sharp, relentless, and focused—yet they truly care about their clients on a personal level. They go above and beyond to ensure justice is served, tackling every case with honesty, intelligence, and compassion. If you’re looking for attorneys who give their all and fight tirelessly for you, look no further. Highly recommend!”

— DK

“I’d like to thank Claudia and the entire Team over by Lieb at Law. You believed in me when nobody else would, and delivered a swift swing of justice. Thank you so much for your patience and making me feel like family.”

— Jamel Williams

“As a lawyer myself, I had a very complex and highly specialized law suit that I placed in the excellent hands of Cheryl Berger at Lieb at Law. It takes an expert to know an expert and I can vouch for Cheryl’s work at the highest level of complex litigation. From the 50-h, through numerous depositions, and court mediation, Cheryl came through time and again, getting us to the finish line with a significant settlement. Thank you Lieb at Law and everyone that helped with our case!”

— Thomas Y

“I came here and natalie Donaldson and the lieb at law group worked to help me. Greatly appreciate them and would recommend to others!”

— kayla Benavides

“The staff at Lieb was great. Andy is a down to earth guy, great sense of humor yet professional. Cheryl was awesome! She was upfront and didn’t make any promises which I greatly respected. Through her emails I saw that she had done research relevant to my case. In under 3 weeks she called to share that they were successful. I highly recommend this firm. Until next time…. Thanks team!!!”

— Patrick

“I had been working with Lieb at law for about 2 years and the courts were still backed up from the pandemic and when we finally got our court date I had the pleasure of Cheryl Berger showing up and getting it all done and then some in one appearance and she was a pleasure to work with. I left there with a weight lifted off my shoulders”

— George S

“I worked with Andrew and Natalie from Lieb at Law over the past few years. They handled my Real Estate legal matters efficiently, and most importantly got the job done. The attorneys at Lieb at Law have a wealth of knowledge when it comes to Real Estate. In addition, Andrew and Natalie always kept me informed, and would always respond to any emails or phone calls in a timely fashion. I would highly recommend them for all your legal needs. Lieb at Law is by far the firm to go to.”

— Neil G

“Hiring Andrew and Cheryl to help with my case was the best decision I could've made. They worked swiftly to resolve the case and I walked away with much more money than anticipated!”

— Andrew M

“Really enjoyed working with Andrew and his team. Deeply knowledgeable, responsive, and quick to solve a problem for us-- a new client.”

— Ryan O

“I was lucky enough to have Mordy Yankovich represent me and help me navigate getting paid from my previous brokerage. From the minute I reached out he made me feel comfortable and confident that he would do what was needed. He was very detailed with reviewing all of my documents and contracts and always had time for my phone calls and 1 million questions! I hope to never need his services again but if I ever do I would not hesitate for one second to choose him again to represent me. Thank you so much Mordy!!”

— Rachel E

“Kimberly at Lieb at Law did an amazing job with my case that was drawn out far too long! Her patience and knowledge of the legal system were my saving grace! Would recommend her 10/10.”

— Julie F

“I was represented by Natalie Donaldson from Lieb at Law, and she is simply the best. In life, cheap is expensive and expensive is cheap. The same goes for any service business — whether it’s a doctor, a lawyer, or a contractor, you hire the best, not the cheapest. How would you like to lose a lawsuit and say, “well, he gave me the best price”? That was never going to be me. I interviewed dozens of attorneys and chose Lieb at Law because I wanted proven performance. Within minutes of my consultation with Natalie, I knew she was the one to represent me. She is efficient, on top of her game, knows the law inside and out, and has the skill to position, present, and navigate a courtroom to get results. Natalie worked with me through financial hardship and still secured the lowest possible settlement. With her representing me, I didn’t feel like the outcome was uncertain — when you hire the best, you get results. The entire Lieb at Law team was outstanding. Andrew Lieb sets the tone for excellence, and his staff delivers. Their assistant Laurin was also extremely helpful and understanding throughout the process. If you want the best, stop looking. Natalie Donaldson and Lieb at Law are who you call.”

— Stefanos C

“We had a really positive experience working with Cheryl Berger at Lieb at Law. Ms. Berger’s communication is clear and efficient. She is extremely diligent, efficient and maintains professionalism, while also handling matters with a sense of kindness and compassion for her client. I have full confidence in her and would highly recommend this attorney.”

— Dan C

“I had an amazing experience with this incredible law firm. Top notch professionalism. I had the pleasure of working with Natalie Donaldson and she proven to be a rockstar! she has displayed a wealth of knowledge/information and experience. Definitely recommend!”

— TristateRealtor

“This firm is the best! They made a very difficult time for me very easy. They take care if you like family!”

— Sarah E

“Wow!! Being a former paralegal, when looking for legal help, I look for litigation firms that represent corporations, then where they are admitted - SDNY, Federal, experience of the lawyers and also if they offer Crises Management The Lieb law firm kept coming up . I I reached out on a Sunday night at 9:15 PM. Lauren responded to me Monday morning at 10:00 AM. Lauren answered my few questions, then explained rates, I booked my appointment IMMEDIATELY . I sent a quick four sentence email on who, what I do in Real estate I also listed three general but pertinent questions to prompt research- ( wasn’t needed, keep reading why ) Day of appointment I was told I would speak to another attorney and not Andrew, I felt like this is not going to be beneficial. Well I was absolutely wrong. So wrong. I was connected with Esquire Claudia Cannam whom was extremely personable engaging and clearly read the questions I sent. Esquire Cannam answered all my questions and gave a clear legal assessment of my issue. I have spoken with many firms about my issues however none, and I mean none were as clear and knowledgeable as Esquire Cannam at The Lieb Law firm. Although I’ve taken my recertification, I’m so impressed with the level of knowledge, I’m going to sign up for theirs just to see what I may have missed with the other recertification course. This is the type of firm you want!”

— Paris Dickey Real Estate Agent